The AI Question We're All Avoiding (And Why I'm Done Pretending)

I was putting together a strategy deck for a client last week when I stopped mid-PowerPoint slide and asked myself a question that made my chest tighten:

"What if AI could do this better than me?"

Not just help me brainstorm or polish my copy. Actually do it better. Faster. Without the therapy breaks and coffee runs that punctuate my creative process.

I'd been watching everyone in my industry treat AI like it's some fancy new calculator. "Use ChatGPT to write your emails!" "Let Claude handle your content calendar!" "It's just a tool to make you more efficient!" But that night, scrolling through LinkedIn while half-watching Netflix, I couldn't shake the feeling that we're all lying to ourselves.

Because the truth is, I'd just spent three hours testing Claude on the exact type of marketing operations challenge I charge thousands to solve. And the output was... uncomfortably good.

Here's what happened: I fed it one of my client's actual problems. The kind of messy, multi-layered operational nightmare that usually takes me a week to untangle. I gave it the context, the team dynamics, the budget constraints, the competing priorities. Everything I'd normally need three discovery calls and a bottle of wine to fully understand.

In five minutes, it delivered a comprehensive operations audit with implementation timeline, resource allocation, and potential risks I hadn't even thought of yet.

My first thought was: "Holy shit, I can work so much faster now!"

My second thought was: "Wait. If AI can do this... what exactly am I selling?"

And my third thought, the one that kept me up scrolling TikTok until 2 AM: "How long until my clients figure this out?"

Everyone's playing the same exhausting game. We're all pretending AI is just making us "more productive" while quietly redesigning our entire value proposition behind the scenes.

I see marketing consultants pivoting to "brand strategy" instead of campaign execution. Operations experts becoming "culture consultants" instead of systems builders. Business coaches focusing on "mindset work" instead of tactical advice.

We're all running from the same uncomfortable truth: AI is really, really good at the stuff people used to pay us for. The analysis, the frameworks, the step-by-step plans, the templates, the "how-to" content that built our businesses.

But we're not talking about it openly because admitting it feels like admitting we might be obsolete.

I had drinks with a fellow founder last month who said, "I don't really use AI. I believe in the human element." Two weeks later, her assistant accidentally cc'd me on an email about "optimizing our AI workflows for client deliverables."

We're lying to ourselves, and we're lying to each other. And honestly? I'm over it.

I'm afraid my dog Daisy will outlive my relevance as a business strategist.

I'm afraid I've spent the last few years building expertise that's about to become as useful as knowing how to use a fax machine.

I'm afraid that the business I built to create freedom might become a prison if I don't adapt fast enough.

But mostly, I'm afraid that by the time I figure out what value I actually provide in an AI world, someone else will have already built the future I'm trying to create.

Here's what I've realized after months of spiraling: The fear isn't the problem. The pretending is.

Once I stopped treating AI like a helpful intern and started treating it like the game-changing technology it actually is, everything shifted. I stopped trying to compete with AI and started figuring out how to dance with it.

And here's the thing that nobody wants to admit but everyone needs to hear: The businesses that will thrive aren't the ones fighting AI. They're the ones that understand what AI can't replace.

AI can spit out a marketing strategy in three minutes. But it can't look at your team dynamics and know that your head of sales is burned out and that's why your pipeline is stalling. It can't read the energy in a client call and pivot the entire conversation because you sense they're not telling you the real problem.

AI gives you the "what." But you still need someone who's lived it to give you the "how" and more importantly, the "what to avoid when everything goes sideways at 11 PM on a Sunday."

The more I work with AI, the clearer it becomes where the real value lives:

AI can create systems. It can't engineer transformation. There's a difference between giving someone a process and creating conditions for actual change. That requires understanding psychology, timing, and how to troubleshoot when human beings inevitably don't follow the plan.

AI can write compelling copy. It can't build trust. People don't hire you because they understand your offer. They hire you because they feel understood. That moment when a client says "It's like you've been inside my business" – that comes from pattern recognition across hundreds of real conversations, not algorithmic analysis.

AI can generate strategy. It can't force execution. And here's where it gets spicy – I keep seeing so-called marketers use AI to spit out these gorgeous, comprehensive strategies, only to watch absolutely nothing happen because there's no follow-up, no accountability, no actual implementation. Strategy is cool and all, but I've seen more businesses die from beautiful PowerPoints than ugly execution. AI can give you a perfect 47-slide deck, but it can't make you uncomfortable enough to actually do the work. It can't call you out when you're avoiding the hard stuff, or push you to ship something imperfect instead of optimizing forever.

AI can analyze data. It can't read between the lines. When a client says "we just need better systems," but you hear "I'm drowning and don't trust my own judgment anymore" – that's wisdom from making your own expensive mistakes, not data processing.

The bias for action? That's still 100% human. And frankly, it's becoming more valuable by the day.

Instead of being afraid of what's changing, I'm getting intentional about how I'm evolving. AI handles the analytical heavy lifting so I can focus on the strategic and intuitive work that actually transforms businesses. It creates the first drafts so I can focus on the judgment, taste, and lived experience that makes the difference between generic advice and game-changing guidance.

Instead of selling information, I'm selling wisdom. Instead of selling templates, I'm selling discernment. Instead of selling what to do, I'm selling what I learned from doing it wrong first.

The golden era of "package your expertise into a course and print money" is over. But the era of depth, discernment, and actual transformation? That's just beginning.

And if you've been building real skills, caring about real results, and developing real wisdom from real failures, you're not behind. You're early to the new game.

The future isn't something that's happening to us. It's something we're creating. The question is: Are we creating it intentionally, or are we letting fear make the decisions?

So here's what I want to know: What's one thing you've been afraid to admit about how AI might be changing your work?

Because I have a feeling I'm not the only one losing sleep over this.

Have ideas for future newsletters?
Hit reply and let me know what you'd like to see!

XX

P.S. Did you love this edit? Take 5 seconds to forward this to a friend who could use some no-bull advice and insights to get them through those “life is life-ing” days.